Intake

From fswiki.us
Revision as of 10:16, 29 April 2022 by SpookySimon (talk | contribs) (→‎Material Choice: Formatting more better, getting rid of unfilled cost table, may add cost back later)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

The intake system has a dominant effect on the torque curve and behavior of the powertrain system. All air used by the engine(s) for combustion must pass through a 20 mm or 19 mm opening for gasoline or E85 fueled vehicles respectively, commonly referred to as a 'restrictor'. The restrictor limits the theoretical power limit of the engine.

Basic Theory

Intake system diagram

The intake system's purpose is to direct ambient air to your engine's air intake.

In forced induction applications, allowing a manifold between the restrictor and throttle body will limit the effects of the restriction. This is negated in FSAE by preventing a large volume (plenum/manifold, intercooler, etc.) prior to the throttle body (Rule IC.2.5.3). The order of system components defined by rules can be seen in the figure right and each component is discussed further down this page.

Intake Design

not sure if good order, WIP

Structure

jargon can go here


Following the path the air follows as it enters the engine, the naturally aspirated intake system is made of the following components: the air filter, the throttle body, the restrictor, the plenum, the manifold, and the engine mounting. The air filter's sole responsibility is to stop water or particulates from entering the engine, these could cause engine damage or even failure. The throttle body allows for driver modulation of mass air flow into the engine, there-by controling engine torque and speed. The plenum acts as a capacitor to smooth air flow into the cylinders and can be tuned to increase volumetric efficiency[citation needed]. The manifold consists of runners that channel air from the plenum into each cylinder. On a port-fuel-injected setup, the fuel injectors will insert fuel into the airstream at the bottom end of the runners. The mounting of the runners to the engine provides structural support to the entire intake system.

Material Choice

The material used for the intake has a much lower impact on the performance than other tuning variables but warrants consideration. The major driving factors to consider are feasibility related: whether it is cost-effective, feasible to create the design the team has made, reliable enough to last through testing and competition, and similar. There are of course differences in the materials chosen that will be discussed here, but is important to understand the material choice is not expected to make a significant difference in dynamic event performance.

Common materials used by teams are below (Please add to this list if I've missed one)

Type Material Construstion Notes
Metals Aluminum Welded sheet and tubing May exchange heat with ambient air if not coated
Plastic Nylon Usually 3D printed Nylon is one of the few 3D printable plastics that is gasoline resistant
Nylon - Glass Fiber Reinforced Usually 3D printed Often outsourced, many institutions do not have in house capabilities to print this or won't want to
Other Off the shelf injection molded Available 3rd party solutions
Composite Carbon Fiber Vacuum bagged, Infusion, Prepreg
Fiberglass Vacuum bagged, Infusion Not as common as carbon fiber

Packaging

I.C.1.2 Packaging Restrictions
Intake Form Factors

Temperature Considerations


Intake Tuning

Tuning takes two forms for the intake manifold: the first is in modifying the length of the manifold (ram tuning) and the second is in modifying the shape of the manifold (including Helmholtz resonators).

Ram Tuning

The basic principle behind ram tuning is that a cylinder intakes air at a particular frequency, i.e. a cylinder only takes in air for a quarter of a four stroke cycle, meaning that there is a stop-starting of the flow of air into the cylinder. This occurs at a frequency dependent on the rpm of the engine, hence ram tuning is done to optimize performance at a selected rpm. The way in which it is implemented is to modify the length of the manifold such that the pressure wave formed on each cycle travels along the manifold and is reflected back, arriving just as the cylinder completes the cycle and takes in its next lot of air. This means that the pressure at the inlet will be higher whenever the engine needs air, giving better volumetric efficiency for the engine.The parameters to adjust regarding ram tuning is the diameter and length of your intake runner, in port injection applications, this is also known as the injector body.


In more complex ram tuning applications, actuated baffles can be created to vary engine torque curve. This is done on many production cars to allow different behavior at low and high RPM.

Trade-Offs

Pros

  • Relatively simple system
  • Allows for movement of your torque curve

Cons

  • Simulations are often inaccurate and may require on vehicle testing to confirm optimal performance
  • Can only tune to one optimal frequency, unless baffles are integrated

Helmholtz Resonators

Helmholtz resonators work by having a thin neck followed by an open cavity attached to the engine's intake. Their design result in low pressure at the neck, sucking in more air, and resulting in higher pressure air in the cavity, which can then feed the engine. Both ram tuning and Helmholtz resonators are simple methods to increase engine efficiency. Helmholtz resonators are most effective in single cylinder systems, as the flow through the intake can be dominated by pulsed flow characteristics at high rpms [citation definitely needed]

Trade-Offs

Mounting

Plenum

Because the engine takes in air in pulses, the airflow out of the intake system is inherently pulsed. The pulsing allows less mass airflow into the system than a smooth airflow would (for many reasons, the most basic of which being that the low pressure waves reduce the airflow more than the high pressure waves increase it).

One useful analogy is comparing the system to a circuit where the output current is pulsed. The restrictor acts as a resistor (hopefully obvious). A basic way to smooth out the circuit is to add a capacitor. In the real world, we do this by adding a volume of air after the restrictor known as a plenum.

The plenum in series with the restrictor creates a pseudo low pass filter that will help smooth out the pulsed air flow characteristics of the intake. Since the restrictor is a fixed size, the "circuit" is tuned by changed the capacity (capacitance hint hint) of the plenum. If the plenum is too small, the non-uniform nature of the intake will significantly decrease power output. If the plenum is too large, the throttle will no longer be able to predictably control the air flow.

The plenum is tuned imperially with many FSAE papers available for comparison.


Throttle Control

Main page: Throttle

The throttle allows modulation of the air coming into your intake system. Within FSAE, the throttle must fall between your restrictor and manifold or, in boosted applications, between the turbocharger/supercharger and manifold. Throttle designs include actuation by throttle cable or by electronic throttle body (ETC or drive-by-wire).

Restrictor Power Limit Derivation

According to IC.2.4.1, the competition requires all air entering the engine to first pass through a 20mm diameter hole when using gasoline or a 19mm hole when using e85. This restrictor places a theoretical upper limit on the power that can be generated by a naturally aspirated engine. The upper limit is derived using the general equation for ideal compressible gas flow:

A
Area
R
Gas Constant

Total Temperature

Specific Heat Ratio
M
Mach number
Total Pressure



when M becomes 1, the flow is considered choked. The equation becomes:

With some basic assumed values at sea level, the maximum mass air flow through the restrictor can be found:

A
3.14 e-4[1]
m2
R
0.286[2]
kJ/kg-K

300
K

1.4[3]
 
M
1
 
101.325[4] kPa


Plugging these into the equation above yields a steady state mass flow rate of 0.074 kg air per second for a 20mm restrictor. A 19mm hole allows 0.067 kg/s of air.

Some ball park power limits can be found as follows: If we assume an AFR of 13.1 (typical lambda for high torque for NA engines[citation needed]), and a QLHV of 43.4 MJ/kg [5] , the mass air flow yields a power limit of 245.1 kW or 328 hp total energy output. If the thermal efficiency of the engine is assumed to be a nominal 33%, the maximum available mechanical power is 81.7 kW or 109 horsepower with 100% volumetric efficiency.

Using an AFR of 8.7 for E85 [6] and a QLHV of 29.2 (citation needed, this was just .85*qlhv ethanol + 0.15 * qlhv gasoline), the limit is 248 kW or 332 hp. The available mechanical power assuming the same efficiency as above is 75.0 kW or 98.5 hp. There are more complexities to using e85 such as the cryogenic effect of fuel vaporization leading to a denser charge, but that is out of the scope for this specific ballpark calculation

This limit can be exceeded by increasing the upstream pressure to greater than 1 atmosphere. In FSAE, any compressor must be placed after the restrictor so this is not possible.

Factors to Consider

  • What is the effect of the pulsed nature of engine air flow? Is this phenomenon consistent throughout the engine's operating range?
  • what is your actual volumetric efficiency?
  • are you operating at Mach # = 1 at all points in the race?


Mach Number vs Mass Flow Rate
  • what is your restrictor's discharge coefficient?
    • well designed venturi style restrictors can see Kd as high as 0.95 [citation needed]
  • is your engine operating at 33% efficiency? that is a rough rule of thumb

Forced Induction

Forced induction is done by utilizing a compressor to increase the pressure seen in your manifold/plenum, leading to increased engine power and efficiency. This is accomplished by the higher manifold pressures being able to force more air into the cylinder/s on each intake stroke. The increased air in the cylinder means you can burn more fuel and maintain the same air-fuel-ratio. A denser charge will also combust faster, yielding greater energy utilization and efficiency. Common methods of implementing forced induction is by turbocharging, supercharging, or procharging. Within FSAE, a fair number of teams run forced induction, but the majority remain naturally aspirated. [7]

Turbocharging

Theory

Turbo system diagram

A turbocharger works by compressing intake air by harvesting waste enthalpy, traditionally discarded, from the exhaust. The general flow of air through a turbocharged system can be seen to the right. Theoretically, the higher plenum pressure you can run, the more power you can extract from your engine package. One limiting factor is self-detonation of the charge or knock. The liability to knock is based upon many factors, including but not limited to, fuel choice, fuel injection location, and compression ratio.

Cooling Charge Air

The charge air cooler, also known as an intercooler, is designed to lower your charge air temperature. The intake air temperature increases due to compression, according to the equation for compressor pressure ratio.



Gamma is 1.4 for dry air. This equation must be used with absolute pressure and temperature. is also known as pressure ratio. For example, a pressure ratio of two (1 atm to 2 atm) will lead to a 20% increase in intake air temperature. This means for an inlet temperature of 20C, your plenum temperature will be approximately 85C. If you run low boost, the need for an intercooler may be able to be avoided. Alternatively, injecting E85 upstream of the runner to cool the air via the evaporation may be feasible. This is only done due to the high latent heat of evaporation and low evaporation temperature for E85. This method is beneficial as it provides cooling and well mixed air fuel mixture. However, this method requires an extremely careful tune otherwise your plenum is liable to turn into shrapnel.

Blow Off Valve=

The purpose of a blow off valve (BOV) is to control your plenum/manifold pressure and prevent compressor surge by dumping excess flow. This works in conjunction with a wastegate to manage plenum pressure to your desired pressure.

Trade-Offs

Supercharging/Procharging

ETS pls

Theory

Trade-Offs

Forced Induction Manifold Designs

For Turbos:

Connecting the intake and exhaust manifolds

  • Over the top
  • Around the side
  • I dont think anyones gone under the engine but im not willing to put money on it

avoid heating intake with exhaust headers

intercooler placement, mounting, (maybe do this in the cooling section?)

  1. For some reason, many of the published theses on FSAE restrictors site a restrictor area of 0.001256m2 which is the area of a 20mm radius circle. Even more baffling is some of these papers then yield a mass flow rate of 0.0703 kg/s which, although somehow close to the correct answer, is still wrong even for the area that they used.
  2. https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/specific-heat-capacity-gases-d_159.html
  3. https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/specific-heat-ratio-d_608.html
  4. https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/air-altitude-pressure-d_462.html
  5. https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/fuels-higher-calorific-values-d_169.html
  6. https://ftyracing.com/tech/lambda-afr-table/
  7. At the 2018 FSAE Michigan competition 9 teams out of 120 (?) openly used forced induction: UMich (CBR), Cornell (CBR), Wisconsin (YZ450), Kettering (WR450), Rose (YZ450), UNC Charlotte (510cc single, KTM?), Minnesota Mankato (YZ450), UNH (KTM 450), Quebec-Chicoutimi (Genesis 80fi), Mississippi (CBR)